Providing health care in Africa tests S. Tahoe doctor’s skills


bannar-3Yesterday I literally had to fight back tears after the first hour. I am not ashamed to say that, but their suffering was very emotional and they have been waiting for some hope.

One patient was seventeen and looked seven. She had terrible deformities from previous burns, but also a belly full of ascites. I think it is the fist case of kwashiorkor I have ever seen.

By Kathryn Reed

Steve Bannar sent several emails like this to family and friends when he was in Tanzania in November administering health care to people who don’t often see doctors with his skills.

The surgeon with Tahoe Orthopedics & Sports Medicine in South Lake Tahoe spent a month with Health Volunteers Overseas in this remote outpost of Africa. It was a test in many ways – in ingenuity, creativity, resolve, and medical know-how.

Though fixing clubfeet is not something he does in his everyday practice, at least it involves orthopedics. For one case the child sucked on his mother’s bosom – that was his anesthetic.

Much of what Bannar was doing in this village near the shores of Lake Victoria had nothing to do with his specialty.

“The basic concepts are the same. The science is the same. It’s more adapting to what is available. You certainly can’t rely on technology,” Bannar said.

Deformities run rampant. They are the result of poor nutrition, parasites and neglect.

Bones stick out. Burns are common. Infections normal. Trauma constant. Mosquito nets help prevent the spread of malaria.

Bannar divided his time between two hospitals – one government run, the other a Catholic facility. The latter being significantly cleaner.

“I have never felt so dirty in my life. I try to be as clean as possible but that is impossible. I saw over thirty patients without soap or towels, nasty. I return to the room to shower and a cockroach the size of a mouse is in there with me,” he writes in an email home.

He had to practice medicine in facilities that are nowhere near what he is used to.

It was a bit of a struggle to get all of his goods through customs, but eventually he made it. Barton Health provided many of the tools he left behind for the medical community to use after his departure. He took lower-tech equipment, but even some of that was more modern than anyone in this village was used to.

“I took the tools to the machine shop to sharpen them for surgery,” Bannar told Lake Tahoe News. “I used a hand drill to put pins in.”

He spent some time with a witch doctor who most of the people believe in. He, too, is a believer.

“I’m not sure how well it works, but it’s been around for a couple thousand years, so it has some validity,” Bannar said of the various potions.

But it was his modern tools that helped an albino be able to feed himself by creating a better pinch on his arm. In this part of the world albinos are said to have magical powers. Their body parts are harvested – even while they are alive. This particular boy had one arm missing and fingers of the other hand cut off.

Despite being steps from Lake Victoria, Bannar couldn’t cool off by swimming in the refreshing looking water. A parasite that goes through the skin lurks beneath the surface.

Rice and fried minnows was a normal meal. Bananas are everywhere and seemed to be put in nearly every dish. Fried grasshoppers are another delicacy of sorts.

“The small intestines [of some unknown creature] was the nastiest, slimiest, chewiest piece of meat I have ever had,” Bannar sends home in an email.

Despite the poverty, the ravaging of forests for fuel, the injuries from motorcycle accidents on roads he decided not to venture out on with two wheels, and the overwhelming need for Western doctors to visit more than once a year, Bannar is ready to go back.

He’s been a member of Health Volunteers Overseas for 15 years, having traveled to Vietnam and St. Lucia.

“It’s really rewarding. I like adventure, to see new cultures,” Bannar said, sitting in the confines of his spacious, clean office. “You eat and live like a national. Instead of going as a tourist and taking, you are giving. You leave something.”

(Click on photos to enlarge.) Photos provided by Steve Bannar.


About author

This article was written by admin


Comments (13)
  1. dogwoman says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    Great story. Reminds us just how good we’ve got it here in the USA. And what sacrifices some people in our town are making for the benefit of the truly poor.
    Thank you.

  2. grannylu says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    Thank you, Steve Bannar, for your contributions to those in need. You are a wonderful example to all of us.

  3. Amanda Adams says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    Dr Bannar fixed my elbow. He is a great doctor. We are very fortunate to have him in our community.

  4. Loreen says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    Wow! Thanks for an incredible story.

  5. the dude says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    Very Cool… Nice work Dr Banner!

  6. LynneBajuk says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    Dr. Bannar is a truly caring surgeon! He “fixed” my 82 year old mother’s hip and when she was in skilled nursing, he visited her with his 2 small children.. they were sweet, caring.. super therapy for a super sweet little lady! How many of us would go to such a poor country to help!!!

  7. Virginia says - Posted: January 7, 2011

    What an uplifting story about what really matters in life. A refreshing departure from the Kubby vs. Davis nonsense.

    Dr. Bannar treated a deformity on my young daughter’s foot and interacted with her as if she was the most important person in the world. His attitude towards treating patients is an inspiration and comes from a strong commitment to timeless principles of compassion and service from the heart.

    We could all take a page out of Dr. Bannar’s book.

    Kudos to Barton too for donating equipment to such a worthy cause. They often contribute to these types of causes and rarely receive recognition.

  8. Monica says - Posted: January 13, 2011

    What a great story! Dr. Bannar is one of my doctors and I have to say “ditto” to all of the comments above. We are lucky to have such a personable and skilled physician here in Tahoe.

  9. Laurie says - Posted: January 13, 2011

    Such a selfless man with great talent!!! We are so fortunate to have some of the best orthopaedic surgeons in the country. I’m impressed with his compassion and generosity.

  10. Paige Rice says - Posted: January 22, 2011

    Dr Banner, Thank you for dedicating your skills to help in Tanzania. I lived in Kenya for a year and realize the need for Medical, educational and technological support. I hope your efforts will spur more people to follow in your foot steps.
    Many thanks

  11. Steve Bannar says - Posted: February 24, 2011

    I want to thank Kathryn Reed for this nice article and the wonderful comments to follow. This trip to Africa was very rewarding. I would like to clarify my feelings about the witch doctors. I do think their is a role for integrative medicine including acupucture, chiropractic care and herbal medicine in the treatment of various ailments. Although these local healers employ some of these techniques they are also unique in that they try to produce both good and evil on other people. They are also responsible for the abuse to the local albinos, therefore I could never endorse any of that activity.
    The entire trip was enlightening and rewarding and I am looking forward to volunteering again.
    Steve Bannar MD

  12. Cindy Aman says - Posted: May 26, 2011

    Dr Bannar… I miss working with you and admire the way you have chosen to go beyond the comfort (and sterility) of US O.R.s. Seeing you there with the people who are greatly in need of care and compassion brings a smile to my soul. They are so fortunate to have you reach out to them. That must have been very “healing” for you too. I can see why you’d do it again. Need an MA to attend next time?! Take care and Thank you, Thank you, Thank you.