THIS IS AN ARCHIVE OF LAKE TAHOE NEWS, WHICH WAS OPERATIONAL FROM 2009-2018. IT IS FREELY AVAILABLE FOR RESEARCH. THE WEBSITE IS NO LONGER UPDATED WITH NEW ARTICLES.

Letter: Our neighborhoods are under attack


image_pdfimage_print

To the community,

Thank you to the “bought and paid for” Mountain Democrat — they receive significant income from the advertising Red Hawk Casino purchases from the paper, God knows you don’t want to bite the hand that feeds you — for bringing us the front page propaganda on the wonderful, exciting and all around beneficial gun range and motocross track. What better way to show that you are a “good neighbor” than for our Indian neighbors to select two significantly intrusive activities that negatively impact the value and enjoyment of the surrounding residential property by the surrounding owners.

The “tribe” decided to place a 29-lane outdoor gun range on property located next to residences and a short distance from two schools and a church because the “community” wanted it soooooo much. I have lived here almost three decades and have never heard one person indicate that we need a 29 lane or any other public or semi-public gun range in Shingle Springs. After protests from local neighbors and community organizations, the “tribe” indicated that they would scale down the 29-lane gun range to a five-lane gun range. Thank God we will only have five guns going off at once next to residences.

So, what better way to show the community that our Indian neighbors understand that we all moved here to have a rural lifestyle than to reduce the gun range to five lanes and add a motocross track. That certainly will not disturb the neighbors. The opening day of the motocross track looked like a race day at Prairie City Off Road Park, trucks and motorcycles everywhere;  people parked along Shingle Springs Drive, (no shoulders), trucks parked in private driveways, significant dust drifting across Highway 50 creating a hazard for everyone traveling east or west, but, not to worry. What the “tribe” wants to do is much more important than neighborhood disruption or public safety; after all, the community has been begging for a gun range and a motocross track. I am sure most of you, the past 20 or 30 years, have sat in the kitchens of your rural homes, each and every Sunday and asked each other, “why don’t we have a gun range and motocross track right next to residential property in Shingle Springs?” Seems natural, doesn’t it?

But the above may only be a diversion. While the community was fighting the gun range and motocross track, the “tribe” has been quietly developing and going forward with plans for a 12-pump fueling station, car wash, two fast food restaurants, hotel and other major commercial development at Shingle Springs Drive on the south-west parcel bordering Highway 50. Why is this a problem? 1) It is bordered by residential properties, 2) the “tribe” will pay no taxes to the county and have taken property off the tax rolls, 3) The “tribe” has applied for a liquor license, (nothing better than the mix of guns and alcohol right across the street from each other), 4) Gas tanks near two schools and a church, 5) Underground gas tanks in an area dominated by parcels with wells, 6) The impact on local tax paying businesses and the resultant reduction of money to the county and reduction of employment opportunities at those local businesses, 7) The significant disruption of the rural lifestyle we all sought in moving to El Dorado County and Shingle Springs, 8) The “tribe” is exempt from state court lawsuits brought by citizens for negligent actions that cause injury to patrons. (Yes, you can sue them in federal court, good luck finding an attorney to bring the action) and oh, yes, I almost forgot, 9) Right in the midst of one of the worst droughts we have seen in our lifetimes, and especially for all of you who are conserving water and letting the lawns you paid your hard earned money for die, EID is about to approve a 12-inch diameter water line along Shingle Springs Drive for the benefit of the Indians’ planned commercial development. They apparently have enough water for the above identified commercial purposes, but not for you.

One more thought, have you wondered why the San Stino project people, now the “Mill Creek” project people, have been so quiet? Here is an answer for you. The San Stino/Mill Creek 1,150 housing project also needs a water line along Shingle Springs Drive. San Stino/Mill Creek will be able to piggy-back on to the Indians’ commercial use infrastructure and “presto-chango” — water for 1,150 homes.

The activities I am identifying are and will take place on land that was not part of the original 160-acre Rancheria. It is taking place on property that was “off-Rancheria” land, previously privately owned by non-Indians and subsequently acquired by the “tribe” by representing to the United States Secretary of the Interior, that none of the off-Rancheria property would be used for commercial purposes. Why is this significant to you? The “tribe” can buy off – Rancheria property anywhere they so desire and then do whatever they desire regardless of the county zoning. The Bureau of Indian Affairs is nothing but a rubber stamp robot, so do not count on the BIA to use common sense or reason or regulate the type of activities tribes decide to do on land they acquire in your neighborhood.

Some have postulated that the “tribe” is engaged in a “land grab”, purposefully taking actions to devalue the surrounding properties so they can pick up parcels cheap for further extended commercial development. Your residential neighborhood can have the same thing happen to it. This is a communitywide concern. The fact that this may not be happening in your back yard right at this time is not a reason to ignore what is going on. The time to act is now. Contact the Board of Supervisors, state representatives, the governor and your federal representatives. Let them know what is happening to our rural neighborhoods and that you do not support this out of control development.

Maureen Sample, Shingle Springs

image_pdfimage_print

About author

This article was written by admin

Comments

Comments (19)
  1. Carl Ribaudo says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    It’s great to hear motocross is back in the greater Placerville region. Historically motocross in the region dates back over 40 years with the origin of Hangtown Motocross before it moved to Plymouth and later to Prairie City. I commend the tribe for bringing back this historically significant activity to the area and providing riders with a local place to race and I look forward to checking out the El Dorado MX track.

  2. Walter C Reinthaler Jr. says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Maureen,

    It sounds like you don’t like to do anytime or have nothing change. Most of the people you talk to are the same way so of course they don’t want change either. I know many families that would love to have a gun range close by. Motocross and Quads are now more family outings. The younger generation of families are more active and doing more things together and not just staying home and baking pies. Enjoy your pie Maureen, Apple Hill is just starting up for the season and enjoy all the traffic.

  3. Atomic says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    …..historically significant motocross activity? Pfffft, that’s comedic. How about a new drag strip raceway behind Carl’s house for the next historically significant activity. Gee, can’t wait. Earplugs are cheap Carl, just think of the history!

  4. Liberule says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Carl: I really hope you’re being sarcastic. If not then You’re an idiot. Plain and simple.

  5. Carl Ribaudo says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    I totally support a motocross track in El Dorado county and I really don’t care if some folks don’t like it. If it’s legal I have no problem with it. It’s a great opportunity for local kids to learn and compete. And yes there is historical significance of motocross in El Dorado County. What is today the Hangtown National Motocross the most prestigious in the country got its early start in El Dorado County. It may not mean much to you but it does to others. Deal with it or hire lawyers.

  6. J&B says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Thank you for raising awareness, Maureen. Our rural quality of life, and our property values, seem to be under constant attack from multiple parties in EDC. If we wanted to live a loud, noisy urban lifestyle, it’s a lot cheaper to move to Sacramento. Clearly we don’t. It is unfortunate that questioning whether a proposed project is appropriate often leads to personal attacks. We miss the original idea of planning – where communities came up with a plan and told those who wanted to build projects what we wanted to see, not the other way around.

  7. Snoplease says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    NIMBY….

  8. Cautious and Skeptical says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    J&B you have correctly assessed the issue. Unfortunately we are in a cycle for updating those plans that were established over 20+ years ago. The agencies have hi-jacked those plans in the name of sustainable communities. The original planning done for communities around Lake Tahoe and surrounding non-suburban areas are why many of us are here today. A little less city and a lot more rural has gone out with the bath water. There needs to be a fair balance/compromise and common sense applied when updating plans. Example: If historic types of activities were to be considered Lake Tahoe would be logged for mining again-hmmm? Carl, hiring lawyers is not the answer. The agencies accuse us of not collaborating and jumping into litigation which seems to be the only recourse when we don’t 100% agree.

  9. Snoplease says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Hey Maureen and J&B! Probably was their land ANYWAY long before you purchased and received “stolen property”! Now your upset that they have their land back (after having to buy back what was stolen from them)??!! Tell me how you feel about someone killing your family, taking your land and house and then selling it back to you.

    NIMBYS….

  10. Steven says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Carl..
    Pretty much your stance on vacation rentals too ? Deal with it or hire lawyers ? Hope you are surrounded by endlessly partying VHRs.

  11. Isee says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    It’s a free-for-all in neighborhoods all over EDC. Nobody’s watching or cares. My residential area became a place for giant outdoor events this year with buses parked on neighborhood streets where there’s no shoulder or sidewalks and let’s not debate 5 hours of amplified sound as to its approperitness. Everything goes now with our current BOS.
    Like they said “call someplace ‘Paradise’ – kiss it goodbye.

  12. hmmm... says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    what Maureen…you’re against the NRA and guns??? Oh the lib-er-al horror!!

    Guess you’re not a REAL American.

  13. Snoplease says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    So then let’s create a regulating agency to watch over EDC then huh?? We can make it just like the TRPA!! Then there will be someone who is ” caring and watching”.

  14. Anonymous says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Maureen,

    Why do you put the word tribe in quotes? (Except when you’re calling them “Indians.”) Please explain.

    What Snoplease said! I feel bad for the loss of the “rural lifestyle” you’re accustomed to, I really do; but it’s so ironic to hear you complain about “Indians” using land in ways that you don’t approve of.

  15. Carl Ribaudo says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Steven I am sure you think you know everything about me or my positions but of course you don’t.
    A motocross track done by a tribe is a completely different set of circumstances. Because it’s a tribe a separate set of laws and rules either get used to or get lawyers.

    As to vacation rentals I have no problem either getting rid of them or keeping them as long as the decision is based on research and information and everyone knows and understands the ramifications of the decision. But of course you knew that.

  16. Atomic says - Posted: October 5, 2015

    Snoplease, handy little reasoning about the Native Americans. I suppose your recent epiphany has caused you to rush down to the assessor’s office and quit claim ownership of YOUR home and land back to them. The injustice of it all must keep you up at night.

    I personally think it is nuts to allow tribes to skirt tax and liability law. How far back do we need to go in history? Which tribe did THEY take THEIR land from? And on and on and on. BS.

  17. snoplease says - Posted: October 7, 2015

    Atomic-

    Just stating the truth sir. No, I’m not going to quit claim my property…how would we be able to fund our local projects without my tax dollars. Anyhow, I’m not the one who wrote this opinion piece.

  18. rock4tahoe says - Posted: October 8, 2015

    Carl is ok with Motocross, shooting ranges and liquor sales at the same venue… Ok. How about multi story buildings in Meyers? Or hog farms along the Truckee River? No better yet, Motocross, Rap Music, shooting ranges, liquor sales and hog farms in Meyers along with a Six Story High Rise?

    Well, since it is on tribal land oh well.

    Hey, maybe the Washoe can buy out some of the slums of Meyers and…

  19. rock4tahoe says - Posted: October 8, 2015

    Atomic. People do keep track of such things as land possessions, births, deaths, feuds etc for decades or centuries. Look at the Catholic versus Protestants debate/violence, Sunni versus Shiites hostilities and Palestinian versus Israelis feud as examples.

    Spain took possession of California away from Native Americans by proclamation and threats in the 1700’s.

    Mexico took possession of California away from Spain via Independence from Spain in the 1820’s.

    The United States took possession of California from Mexico via the Mexican-American War in the 1840’s.

    Some people have donated land to Native American Tribes. I believe the Washoe Tribe recently received some land at/near Baldwin Beach via settlement with the Forest Service.